Independent archive of oregonwatercoalition.org, 2007–2023 · not affiliated with the Oregon Water Coalition Hermiston · Umatilla Basin · lower Columbia
Oregon Water Archive

Water, farms and power in northeastern Oregon, from the pages of Oregon Water Online and the coalition’s website

Chinook salmon leaping up white water beside rocks
Salmon & riversOregon Water Online

A Chinook salmon jumping upstream.

Oregon Water OnlineSalmon & riversEnergy & hydropower

Studying juvenile steelhead from release to adult return

Originally published
Posted by OWC Filed under Engineering, Environment, Federal, Fish/Wildlife Habitat, Scientific/Research Archive capture: March 30, 2016

Restored from Oregon Water Online, the 2009–2016 news blog, as captured on March 30, 2016. The text is kept as published; many items were reposts of regional news, and their source line is kept at the end. Dead links and contact details have been removed.

Research biologists in Washington state have found that when juvenile hatchery steelhead leave the hatchery rearing pond when they are ready to emigrate – of their own volition, as it were – that they tend to return as adults in larger numbers.

And they “residualize” (remain in-stream after release) at a lower rate than those juveniles that fail to emigrate and must be forced from the hatchery.

Their research suggests that juvenile hatchery steelhead that fail to emigrate of their own volition tend to hang out in the stream as “residual” hatchery steelhead, crowding and competing for food in the stream they share with wild steelhead that are often listed under the U.S. Endangered Species Act.

Their conclusion is that it is better not to release these fish into the native stream at all.

Charles G. Snow and Andrew R. Murdoch of the Washington Department of Fish & Wildlife, along with Thomas H. Kahler of the Public Utility District No. 1 of Douglas County, located in Wenatchee, published “Ecological and Demographic of Releasing Nonmigratory Juvenile Hatchery Steelhead in the Methow River, Washington” in the North American Journal of Fisheries Management in December 2013, but they had completed the study in early 2013.

Snow is a WDFW biologist, who also supervises WDFW’s Methow Research Team. Murdoch is a research scientist, supervising WDFW Science Division’s Hatchery-Wild Interactions Unit. The Methow Research Team, which conducted this study, is a part of his responsibilities. Kahler is a fisheries biologist with Douglas County PUD.

Building on earlier research, the researchers were able to tag onto a U.S. Army Corps of Engineers survival study on the mainstem Columbia River in which the Corps needed to PIT-tag 240,000 steelhead juveniles from WDFW’s Wells Hatchery in each of three years of the study.

“This was a huge tagging number that we could never have done ourselves because of the cost,” said Snow. “So we just capitalized on their effort as best we could.”

“We were building on the research of Viola and Schuck (1995) to show that a volitional migration release methodology could effectively segregate steelhead into migrant and non-migrant groups of fish,” Snow said, which is also what Viola and Schuck did.

“But what we were able to do in addition was to show that most residual hatchery summer steelhead comes from the non-migrant group of fish, and we quantified what the effect would be on the number of residual fish released and subsequent adult returns if the non-migrant group of fish were not released into anadromous waters.”

Juvenile hatchery steelhead are typically released into a river when they reach 14 to 16 months, regardless of their maturity, in order to meet annual release goals. Yet, wild steelhead tend to rear in the river for one to seven years, according to Snow et al, but generally tend to emigrate when two years to three years old.

“Given the observed survival advantage afforded to larger individuals, steelhead hatchery programs that only release yearling fish are selecting for individuals that grow faster within the hatchery environment. This trait may not be ideal for fish intended to supplement a natural population where age at emigration is typically two or more years.”

Hatchery juveniles are often released based on hatchery goals of providing fish for harvest, they say, yet subtle changes could be made if the goal was “recovery or rebuilding natural populations, while minimizing the negative impacts often associated with hatchery production.”

The unwitting result of current hatchery management goals is that more of the hatchery steelhead, the nonmigratory juveniles (NM), remain in the river and contribute more to stream-resident populations rather than to migratory fish that return as adults.

In fact, according to Snow et al, it may be better not to release these fish from the hatchery at all, thus avoiding the “ecological cost of increased competition, predation, and genetic contribution through precocity….” That would reduce the number of residual hatchery fish in the stream by 70 percent, while reducing the total adult returns by only 2.8 percent.

“If the non-migrant group of fish were planted in a lake instead (to enhance sportfishing for example), there would be little effect on adult steelhead returns in subsequent years, but a great reduction in the negative aspect of residual fish in regards to competition and predation,” Snow said.

Columbia Basin Bulletin

More on salmon & rivers