Oregon Water OnlineSalmon & riversEnergy & hydropower
Hatchery aimed at restoring Salmon in Okanagan Basin
Restored from Oregon Water Online, the 2009–2016 news blog, as captured on February 13, 2010. The text is kept as published; many items were reposts of regional news, and their source line is kept at the end. Dead links and contact details have been removed.
A proposal by the Colville Tribes to build a salmon hatchery near central Washington’s Chief Joseph Dam appears to have cleared another procedural hurdle with the release last month of what is a mostly positive final Environmental Impact Statement.
The document was prepared by the Bonneville Power Administration to satisfy National Environmental Policy Act requirements.
The EIS describes a handful of negative environmental impacts from the construction and operations of the hatchery, such as increased dust and vehicle exhaust locally during construction, balanced against an extensive list of socioeconomic and other benefits. “We just got great support from the public,” BPA’s Mickey Carter said of the process leading to the final EIS.
A draft was offered for public comment in May 2007. The 10 comments received from individuals and from federal, state, tribal and local entities were categorized and responded to in the final EIS.
BPA and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which owns and operates the dam, expect to issue “records of decision” based on the public comments and the analysis in the FEIS by March on whether to implement the Chief Joseph Hatchery Program. If BPA and the Corps decide to proceed with the project, activities could begin in spring 2010.
“We’re actually negotiating a construction contract now” so that work could begin immediately if positive RODs are issued, said Linda Hermeston, BPA project manager.
The Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation first launched the proposal in 2001 through the Northwest Power and Conservation Council’s Columbia River Basin Fish and Wildlife Program. BPA funds the Council program to mitigate for impacts to fish and wildlife from the construction and operation of the Columbia-Snake hydro system.
The tribes aim to boost summer-fall chinook returns and reintroduce spring chinook, a species that was long ago extirpated in the Okanogan River system. The Okanogan flows into the Columbia below Chief Joseph, which blocks salmon passage to historic spawning grounds upstream.
The Council in May gave the go-ahead for the tribe complete final design for the construction of the hatchery.
NOAA Fisheries Service in a July 2008 issued “biological opinion” that said the proposed construction and operation of Chief Joseph Hatchery “is not likely to jeopardize the continued existence” wild Upper Columbia spring chinook salmon or steelhead, two stocks that are listed under the Endangered Species Act.
Estimates presented last spring peg construction costs at $37 million over two years, with completion in 2011.
Total cost for all aspects, including planning and design, and construction, is estimated to be $40.8 million. Annual operation and maintenance costs after facilities are fully developed would cost an estimated $2.1 million annually and monitoring and evaluation is estimated to cost about $735,000 each year.
In a memorandum agreement signed by BPA, the Corps and the Bureau of Reclamation in May 2008, BPA agreed to make capital funds available to construct the proposed hatchery subject to NPCC review and meeting all legal compliance conditions. The Corps agreed to support the planning, design and construction of the hatchery.
The proposed hatchery would support the goal of the Colville Tribes to produce adequate salmon to sustain tribal ceremonial and subsistence fisheries and enhance the potential for a recreational fishery for the general public.
The FEIS discloses the environmental effects expected from facility construction and program operations.
The hatchery complex would be located on Corps property near Chief Joseph dam, so the federal agency is a cooperating agency under NEPA. The Corps, Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife, Washington Parks and Recreation, the Oroville-Tonasket Irrigation District, and others cooperated on project design and siting.
The project has two components: 1) to increase the abundance, distribution and diversity of naturally spawning summer/fall chinook within their historical Okanogan subbasin habitat; 2) reintroduce extirpated spring chinook back into the Okanogan River.
The project was designed to make certain the hatchery would not affect the operation of the dam of the Federal Columbia River Power System (e.g., spill, timing, dissolved gases, etc.) or the power system operational flexibility.
Another requirement was that it not adversely affect ESA populations via mixed stock harvest, reduced productivity of the wild fish or other factors. The project was designed to make certain it is aligned with FCRPS BiOp prescriptions, ESA recovery objectives or hatchery operational principles recently developed by the Hatchery Scientific Review Group.
Planners also wanted to make certain that the hatchery operations had minimal effects on water quantity and use irrigation and municipal withdrawals.
Component 1 of the hatchery supplementation program is designed to produce 1,100,000 summer-fall chinook smolts annually. Component 2 would produce an additional 500,000 early-arriving and 400,000 late-arriving summer/fall chinook hatchery smolts primarily for harvest purposes.
A third component involves producing 900,000 spring chinook smolts in an effort to return naturally spawning spring chinook to their historical Okanogan subbasin habitat and in the Columbia River between the Okanogan River and Chief Joseph Dam. Those could also increase the potential for tribal ceremonial and subsistence fisheries and recreational fishing opportunities.
The spring chinook component could eventually contribute to the recovery of the ESA-listed Upper Columbia River stock.
The summer/fall chinook components production would involve developing local broodstock, propagating the full historical run of summer/fall chinook by extending the current broodstock collection by two months and raising yearling and subyearling life stages, improving spawning distribution throughout their historical habitat and controlling the proportion of hatchery-origin fish spawning naturally.
Water to the hatchery would come from three sources: Rufus Woods Lake, a relief tunnel that collects seepage from the abutment of Chief Joseph Dam, and a well field.
Summer/fall and spring chinook salmon incubated and reared at the hatchery would be released into the Columbia River there or transported to ponds along the Okanogan River and Omak Creek for final rearing, acclimation and release.
A comprehensive monitoring and evaluation plan is being developed to evaluate general program success.
“Some benefit to local economy could be realized if chinook recover and stimulate fishing and related recreation and tourism. No measurable effects to area housing, utilities, schools, law enforcement, or tax base are predicted,” according to the FEIS.
The entire FEIS and supporting information may also be viewed at bpa.gov.