Independent archive of oregonwatercoalition.org, 2007–2023 · not affiliated with the Oregon Water Coalition Hermiston · Umatilla Basin · lower Columbia
Oregon Water Archive

Water, farms and power in northeastern Oregon, from the pages of Oregon Water Online and the coalition’s website

Black-and-white photograph of an irrigation flume crossing a river channel in open country
Water rights & lawOregon Water Online

Irrigation dam, flume and spillways on the Umatilla River near Pendleton, 1900–1910.

Oregon Water OnlineWater rights & lawSalmon & rivers

Groups challenge Lake Roosevelt drawdown and water rights

Originally published
Filed under Climate, Courts, Dams, Environment, Federal, Fish/Wildlife Habitat, Flows, Reservoir/Storage, State, Water Supply/Consumption Archive capture: March 7, 2009

Restored from the 2007–2009 Oregon Water Online blog, as captured on March 7, 2009. The text is kept as published; many items were reposts of regional news, and their source line is kept at the end. Dead links and contact details have been removed.

A pair of environmental groups on Monday filed a lawsuit aimed at stopping the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation from drawing down the mid-Columbia River’s Lake Roosevelt more deeply in summer.

Targeted is the Lake Roosevelt Incremental Storage Release project developed by the state of Washington’s Department of Ecology in collaboration with the Bureau. The groups’ complaint, filed in Western Washington’s U.S. District Court in Seattle, says the Bureau broke federal environmental laws by failing to prepare either an environmental assessment or environmental impact statement for the project.

Such reviews provide a public airing of the potential consequences of the drawdown.

“The Bureau has sidestepped our most basic public participation laws in deciding to divert yet more water from the Columbia River. The public has a fundamental right to weigh in on these issues before the government gives away public resources,” said Chris Winter of the Crag Law Center. Winter is representing Columbia RiverKeeper and the Center for Environmental Law & Policy in the lawsuit.

The groups say the lawsuit’s outcome could have a major impact on water in the West because of the looming issues of climate change, water shortages, cost to taxpayers and the major role of the Bureau in managing the West’s water.

“Climate change will only aggravate problems already facing the Columbia River,” said Rachael Paschal Osborn, CELP’s director. “The Bureau must first analyze climate change impacts and the enormity of the taxpayer and ratepayer subsidy before taking more water from the Columbia River.”

The organizations want reviews of five major issues:

  • The effect of climate change on the Columbia River
  • The effect of lowering water levels of Lake Roosevelt and exposing toxic slag deposited by the Teck Cominco smelter just north of the U.S.-Canadian border
  • Impacts on river flows needed by migrating salmon
  • The cumulative effects of the multiple proposals for new dams and new water projects that would take water from the Columbia River
  • The costs to taxpayers and ratepayers for expanding the nation’s largest federal reclamation project – the Columbia Basin Project

Such issues need to be explored with the development, and public vetting, of a EA and/or EIS as required by the National Environmental Policy Act and Council on Environmental Quality regulations implementing NEPA, according to the complaint filed Monday. Such reviews are required for every major federal action that has a significant impact on the environment, the groups say.

The WDOE on Sept. 25 delivered two “reports of examination” to Bill McDonald, the Bureau’s Pacific Northwest regional director. The state agency decisions outline how 82,500 acre-feet of water drawn from Lake Roosevelt will be distributed throughout the central Columbia Basin.

The ROEs represent secondary water use permits for water stored in Lake Roosevelt under a 1938 water right issued to the Bureau by the state. The federal agency owns and operates Grand Coulee Dam, which backs up Lake Roosevelt.

The Lake Roosevelt Incremental Storage Release Project involves withdrawing additional water from Lake Roosevelt to provide drought relief, improve municipal and industrial supply, alternatives to ground water use in the Odessa Subarea, and streamflow enhancement for fish downstream of Grand Coulee Dam.

Annually, 82,500 acre-feet would be released from storage, resulting in approximately a 1-foot additional drawdown of the lake by the end of August. In drought years, Reclamation would release 50,000 acre-feet, in addition to the 82,500 acre-feet released for storage. That would result in an addition 1.8-foot drawdown. All incremental releases would occur in July and August.

The complaint asks the court to declare illegal a memorandum of understanding signed by the Bureau, state of Washington and three irrigation districts that committed the federal agency to helping develop water supply projects. It also says the Bureau’s applications for the water rights to implement the drawdown are illegal.

The groups also want the court to issue a restraining order, a preliminary injunction or a permanent injunction to prevent the Bureau from using the water rights before NEPA compliance is assured.

The two environmental groups are also challenging the drawdown project at the state level. On Oct. 23 they filed an appeal with the state Pollution Control Hearings Board. It faults the state for issuing the water rights.

The CELP-Riverkeeper appeal says the decisions:

  • Are outside the scope and intent of the primary reservation of water by the bureau, which owns and operates the dam
  • Fail to consider and address impacts of climate change, cumulative withdrawals and other factors that affect water availability, in-stream flows, and aquatic life and habitat in the Columbia River watershed
  • Harm the public interest because of the substantial public subsidies associated with the water diversions
  • Harm the public interest because of impacts caused by drawdown of the Lake Roosevelt reservoir pool

The plan’s potential impacts were evaluated by the state in a supplemental environmental impact statement released in late August. It evaluates impacts associated with several Lake Roosevelt water release scenarios.

It chose as the preferred alternative an adaptive management approach to schedule the flow releases. A panel of fisheries and water experts would determine the amount and timing of the flows each year based on runoff predictions for the Columbia River. The flow releases would be timed to provide maximum benefits for fish, the SEIA cover letter says.

The SEIS also says that the Bureau “will evaluate the steps necessary for compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) when it issues service contracts for use of the water.”

The actual water use permits were delivered to the Bureau Dec. 1.

“There’s a lot to work to be done,” said the Bureau’s area manager Bill Gray. “This is just the first step in the process.

The federal agency would ultimately develop at least one contract with the state for the release of 37.5 kaf - 25 kaf for downstream municipal and industrial uses and 12.5 kaf for flow augmentation for fish. Another contract would have to be struck with the irrigation districts for the designated release of 45 kaf - 30 kaf to replace underground water sources in a depleted Odessa aquifer and 15 kaf to augment flows.

The Bureau intends to carry out NEPA review before the contracts are finalized, Gray said.

Columbia Basin Bulletin

Added in 2026

Context for “Groups challenge Lake Roosevelt drawdown and water rights”

Lake Roosevelt is the reservoir behind Grand Coulee Dam, built between 1933 and 1942 and now the largest power station in the United States by nameplate capacity. Water drawn from it feeds the Columbia Basin Project, the country's largest reclamation project, which irrigates over 670,000 acres in central Washington.

What is the Columbia Basin Project?

The Bureau of Reclamation irrigation network made possible by Grand Coulee Dam, serving more than 670,000 acres through three irrigation districts.

More on water rights & law